Top Social


Saturday, November 15, 2014

Oh, sigh. Where do I begin? As a huge advocate of I was super excited about the lazy version If you aren't familiar with Poshmark click here because I wrote about it on a previous post (and I still adore the site). Poshmark is a free iPhone/iPad app that allows you to shop the closets of women across the country and also sell your own clothes. I've had a bunch of successful sales on the site and if you are interested here is a link to my closet click here. At first I was thrilled with the idea of ThredUp because it seemed a lot easier than Poshmark. You'd simply ship the company your clothes and they would sell them for you! One of the most difficult aspects of Poshmark is keeping track of your items and convincing people to purchase them. It can take weeks to months to make a sale especially if you aren't consistently pushing the items out. You also have to take the time to take photos of the items or model them to grab the attention of the buyer.

Here is my first big tip when dealing with sites like these, always research beforehand. If I had researched ThredUp prior to working with them I would have found the negative reviews that they have received online from other sellers. What amazes me is that they acknowledged how many scam complaints they've received and wrote about it on a blog last year click here. In the blog entry they wrote "We can’t stay in business unless we keep buying items from you." Oh really? Now, let's jump into my nightmare ..

The Nightmare:
A few weeks ago I sent ThredUp a variety of items in a bag, one of these items was a practically new Marc by Marc Jacobs blazer (photograph below) that I barely wore. After a year of seeing it in my closet I decided to try and sell it. Although, I could of sold it on Poshmark I decided to see how much money I could get for selling it through Thred Up. When you sign up for the service ThredUp sends you a large bag with a shipping label and a note card with instructions. For the purpose of this blog entry I am going to focus on the prize item - the jacket and nothing else. It was a freshly laundered, brand name, no signs of wear and tear blazer so I thought I was good to go!

According to their Quality Standards thredUP's #1 objective is for the customer to have a great time using their Clean Out service. Unfortunately, I had a horrible time. I reached out to the company immediately when they emailed and said that the jacket could not be sold on the site. What? Why? I followed every rule they listed. This is the response I got back from Brandie: 

I went to this website page she directed me to and scrolled to the bottom of the page and saw a random note ***Please note we are currently limiting our intake of dress pants, blazers, and work wear. Please contact our team at with any questions*** The problem with this language is that it still doesn't explain why my blazer couldn't be accepted. Using the word "limiting" doesn't mean "do not send us" and if this was so important to the company, why wouldn't they make sure that people saw this information by placing it at the very top of the page and/or including a separate note when they send out cleaning bags. I expressed my concerns and Brandie responded back.

You know why I didn't opt for insurance? Because I thought my jacket would be chosen, why? because it was exactly what they wanted the items to be. Freshly laundered, a well known brand in top condition, and according to the blog entry there is absolutely zero reason why they'd try and not buy items from me. When was that "limiting" note added? Let's say I was a frequent customer who often sold items before the note was posted and I was already familiar with the quality standards, how would I know about their new "limiting of items" policy? I wouldn't. To expect customers to read that page each and every time for notifications is absurd. All notices that important should be included on the top of the page or provided with the clean out bag. I asked Brandie why they don't just write "We do not accept" instead of using the word "limiting." It's very confusing to the seller, how would one know which items to send and not send? Here is the response I got ... 

So ... how am I supposed to know when they've reached their limit? I immediately went to the website to see the Marc by Marc Jacobs that passed the test and weren't tossed away like mine. Surely, they must be amazing if they decided to keep them. 

Well, not really. Don't they look as good as the one I was trying to sell them? Doesn't my jacket perhaps look better than some of these options? Needless to say I'm very disappointed. My only hope is that it was donated to a charity, and a ThreadUp employee isn't wearing the jacket to work every day. If I had one piece of advice for the company it would be to change the language and communicate more effectively with sellers. If you really can't sell certain items and are "limiting" certain items you should notify sellers immediately by placing the note at the top of the page, not at the bottom where they are unlikely to see it. You should also include the information with the clean out bags. You should also tweet the information to remind people. It looks like I'm sticking with Poshmark for now.

Do you know of an effective way to sell clothing? Share below.

14 comments on "THRED UP GETS A THUMBS DOWN! "
  1. Ahh this sucks! Bad for the business and brand, too! I just received a Thred Up package, and now I don't think I will use them.

    1. Good idea, I wouldn't suggest selling items through them. I'm sure buying from the site is fine but I still don't want to support them because I feel like they are scamming people. Poshmark is a better choice : )

  2. This is really unfortunate. I know a lot of people who use these online selling sites (I've used some before) and this sounds like a horror story. Their language of "limited" isnt clear at all and they should work with the customer rather then send replies that your clothing is on a recycling truck. I'm sure someone in the office is probably wearing your blazer or their cousin is wearing it around the neighborhood.

  3. i had a similarly disappointing experience with thred up! they were nice enough to send me something from the site, which was awesome, but when i sent in a whole bag of clothing, they told me that none of the items were acceptable and sent me pictures where there were microscopic problems with everything. most of the pieces i sent were vintage, so that is to be expected, but i am sure there was something sellable out of a whole bag! i was left with a bad taste in my mouth from a site that seemed like a fun way to sell your clothes. i am on poshmark too!


  4. I was so disappointed with thredUP! I followed their instructions exactly, and even put in one designer item that I had NEVER worn! They accepted nothing, and now I feel like a fool. If I wanted to give my things away, I could do it myself!

  5. Thredup stole a few hundred dollars worth of clothes from me two years ago. After rejecting my items and refusing to return them, I found several of them up for sale on their site. I'm still pissed about it.

  6. Thredup is pure garbage. I sent them a bag of designer goods and items with the tags still on and they paid me a fraction of the cost of one the items that I sent them. Then I go and see them list the items that I sold them for double and triple what they paid me. If you want to buy from them you'll most likely like what you get. If you sell to them I can guarantee you will disappointed with your payout. Just send your stuff to Goodwill. I bet their staff is walking around in the stuff they wouldn't take from me. Waste of time and energy and I won't bother with them anymore.

  7. ThreadUp is a scam!!! I got $2 for kids clothing (some of which they sold as girls or women's). It included Ralph Lauren, Levis, H&M, JCrew --some with tags still on. I would have gotten more from giving it to GoodwIll or a friend. They have taken six months to answer my inquiries and only did so after I filed a BBB complaint. Do not use the clean out bag, I did because it was lying around and I got $2 --which I have to request through paypal, since they don't automatically send it to you.

  8. Uhhhh watch out for poshmark!!!!! They side with buyer,,i had 500$ dresses for sale with tags and acceoted about 120 each, i was happy with that but one skank bag left me a bad review saying i sent her a dirty dress. I flipped out. See thats what these scammers do on posh, they report you saying dirty unwashed item, poshmark sides with them and they get to keep the item. Its crazy. My scammer gave me 1 star and i redponded to her " i know uou are trying to scam me and keep the dress blah blah blah. It was not a nice message. She suddenly gave me 5 stars when i called her out,,it was my first time and i was a newbie. These scammers preybon the newbies. Most on poshmark are teenagers too, oh and i contacted posh about the situation and about 2 weeks went by and got some lame respond. I HATE them. Plus its all social media. Its a huge scam joke!!

  9. I sent a bag of clothes; kids, and plus size sweaters/jeans/shorts, and I was awarded 12$ for a WHOLE BAG full of clothes/shoes/dresses, and i got nothing for my trouble. I will never shop or donate to those scam artists again. I never received the check either.


Auto Post Signature